The Front Room is a film that defies easy categorization. Written and directed by Max and Sam Eggers, the younger brothers of acclaimed filmmaker Robert Eggers, this movie combines elements of dark comedy and psychological drama, resulting in a strange yet intriguing mix. Based on Susan Hill’s 2016 short story of the same name, it tells the story of a young heavily pregnant couple, Belinda (Brandy) and Norman (Andrew Burnap) who find themselves reluctantly caring for Norman’s estranged ailing stepmother, Solange (Kathryn Hunter). What unfolds is a chaotic ride filled with unexpected humor, disturbing moments and an over-the-top portrayal of familial strife.
Plot Overview
The story centers on Belinda a college lecturer and her husband Norman a lawyer working for free to help those in need. Financially struggling they receive the news that Norman’s father has died, leaving behind a strange request: for his widow Solange, a woman who made Norman’s childhood a nightmare to live with them for the rest of her days. In return they will inherit her considerable wealth.
Initially, the couple is hopeful that it will be manageable but they quickly realize that Solange is far from an ordinary elderly lady. She is a disruptive almost diabolical presence in their lives and what follows is a series of bizarre events that blur the line between reality and nightmare. As tensions rise Solange’s behavior becomes increasingly erratic leading to confrontations that are as hilarious as they are uncomfortable.
Performance Highlights
Kathryn Hunter shines in the role of Solange bringing a sinister yet oddly comedic energy to the character. Her portrayal of the spiteful manipulative stepmother is one of the film’s strongest points. Hunter’s performance is so captivating that she manages to steal nearly every scene she’s in making even the most absurd moments compelling to watch.
Brandy known for her music career and earlier acting roles delivers a surprisingly strong performance as Belinda, the weary yet determined pregnant wife. She brings a relatable sense of frustration and vulnerability to her character, effectively portraying a woman caught between her loyalty to her husband and her growing dread of their unwanted houseguest. Her chemistry with Andrew Burnap, who plays her often clueless and passive husband, adds an additional layer of humor to the film.
The Film’s Tone and Style
The Front Room is a black comedy with a heavy emphasis on the absurd. The humor is dark and occasionally crude with a significant amount of bodily functions, strange rituals and surreal dreams. At times, the film ventures into deeply unsettling territory—such as Solange’s bizarre religious practices and her unnerving interactions with the newborn baby—only to pivot back to over-the-top comedic moments.
This contrast between horror and humor is a double-edged sword. While the film has plenty of laugh-out-loud moments, it sometimes struggles to maintain a consistent tone. The Eggers brothers seem torn between wanting to create a genuine psychological thriller and a dark comedy ultimately ending up with a film that doesn’t fully commit to either.
What Works and What Doesn’t
What Works:
- Performances: Kathryn Hunter’s performance as Solange is the movie’s standout element, bringing a chilling yet oddly funny presence. Brandy also brings warmth and realism to her role making her character relatable.
- Humor: If you enjoy dark offbeat comedy there’s plenty to laugh at here. The film’s willingness to be ridiculous and outrageous gives it a unique charm.
- Unpredictability: The film constantly plays with the audience’s expectations making for a viewing experience that is both unpredictable and engaging.
What Doesn’t Work:
- Inconsistent Tone: The movie’s attempt to blend horror with comedy is ambitious but doesn’t always hit the mark. At times, the tonal shifts can feel jarring and leave the audience unsure of what the film is trying to be.
- Repetition: Some scenes and themes feel repetitive, which can make the film drag in parts. The constant back-and-forth between conflict and attempted resolution can get tiring.
- Lack of Depth: While the film hints at deeper themes—like family dynamics, motherhood and manipulation—it doesn’t explore them fully. This makes the film feel somewhat hollow, especially for those looking for more substance beneath the surface.
Final Thoughts
The Front Room is a messy but ultimately entertaining film that will appeal to fans of dark campy comedies. While it may not satisfy everyone especially those expecting a straightforward horror experience, its unique blend of absurdity, psychological tension and standout performances make it good a watch. Kathryn Hunter’s brilliant turn as the menacing stepmother along with Brandy’s strong performance, keeps the film interesting even when its script and direction falter.
If you can embrace its bizarre humor and are prepared for some gross-out moments, The Front Room is a wild ride that offers a fresh take on the horror-comedy genre. Just be warned: it’s not for the faint-hearted or those who prefer their comedies without a side of chaos.
Rating: 3/5 stars – A peculiar film that may not stick the landing for everyone, but offers enough quirky moments and memorable performances to make it an interesting watch.